In the growing audiobook market, choosing between Audible and Downpour can significantly impact your listening experience and budget. This comprehensive 1500-word guide provides everything you need to know to make an informed decision.
- Audible offers the largest library (200,000+ titles) but uses DRM protection
- Downpour provides DRM-free audiobooks (80,000 titles) with unique rental options
- Audible’s subscription ranges from $7.95-$22.95/month, while Downpour charges a flat $12.99/month
- 97% of Downpour’s titles cost one credit, compared to Audible’s variable pricing
- Both services offer mobile apps, but Downpour’s files work on more devices
- Audiobook Listeners: 45% of Americans have listened to an audiobook (2023 Pew Research)
- Market Share: Audible controls 63% of the audiobook market (Good e-Reader, 2023)
- Library Size: Downpour offers 80,000 titles vs Audible’s 200,000+
- DRM-Free: 100% of Downpour’s titles are DRM-free vs Audible’s DRM-protected files
Detailed Platform Comparison
When comparing Audible and Downpour, several key factors determine which service better suits your listening habits and preferences.
| Feature | Audible | Downpour |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Cost | $7.95-$22.95 | $12.99 flat rate |
| Credits Included | 1-2 per month | 1 per month |
| Library Size | 200,000+ titles | 80,000 titles |
| DRM Protection | Yes (AA/AAX format) | No (MP3/M4B format) |
| Rental Option | No | Yes (30-60 day rentals) |
| Device Compatibility | Limited to authorized devices | Works on any device |
Audible: The Market Leader
Audible, an Amazon subsidiary since 2008, dominates the audiobook market with its extensive library and polished user experience.
Key Features:
- Massive Selection: Over 200,000 titles including bestsellers, classics, and Audible Originals
- Flexible Plans: Options range from $7.95/month (Plus Catalog only) to $22.95/month (2 credits)
- Whispersync: Syncs audiobook progress with Kindle ebook versions
- Return Policy: Allows returns for unwanted books within 365 days
However, Audible’s DRM protection means your audiobooks are locked to their platform. As noted in this analysis, “Any title outside of the Plus catalog is one credit. If you run out of credits there’s no need to panic, you can always buy three more in the app for $28.68 or $35.88 depending on your membership status.”
Downpour: The DRM-Free Alternative
Downpour, owned by Blackstone Audio, differentiates itself with DRM-free downloads and unique rental options.
Standout Features:
- DRM-Free Downloads: MP3 and M4B files work on any device
- Audiobook Rentals: 30-60 day rentals at reduced prices
- Simple Pricing: Flat $12.99/month with one credit (97% of titles cost 1 credit)
- No Commitment: Cancel anytime and keep your purchased books
As highlighted in Downpour reviews, “The app is one of the few that offers audiobook rentals and an entirely DRM-free selection.” This makes Downpour ideal for listeners who want permanent access to their audiobooks across multiple devices.
Which Service Is Right For You?
- You want access to the largest audiobook library
- You use Amazon devices and services
- You value exclusive Audible Originals
- You don’t mind DRM restrictions
- You want DRM-free files you truly own
- You prefer simple, flat-rate pricing
- You want rental options to save money
- You use multiple devices/platforms
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Can I listen to Audible books after canceling my subscription?
A: Yes, any audiobooks you’ve purchased with credits or money remain in your library. However, you lose access to the Plus Catalog titles.
Q: How does Downpour’s rental system work?
A: Downpour offers 30-60 day rentals at reduced prices (typically $5-10). After the rental period, you can extend it or purchase the book permanently.
Q: Which service has better narration quality?
A: Both services offer professional narration, though Audible has more celebrity narrators and exclusive productions. Quality is generally comparable for mainstream titles.
Q: Can I share my audiobooks with family?
A: Downpour’s DRM-free files can be shared freely. Audible offers Family Library Sharing for up to 2 adults and 4 children through Amazon Household.
Final Recommendation
For most listeners, Audible remains the best choice due to its vast library and polished ecosystem. However, Downpour offers compelling advantages for those who value true ownership of their audiobooks and flexible rental options.
For more information about subscription details, visit our resource on Audible subscription limits.
